Talk:Voltage controlled filter

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Draft revision

Move this into the article once it's tidy enough.

Donald Tillman's filter taxonomy

Filter architectures (sorry this is crudely laid out, 1st step was capture info, 2nd pass will organize) Consider a description of a filter as a sort of "taxonomy" with three layers:

  • Top Layer: the filter spec, number of poles, response
  • Middle Layer: the topology that implements that filter function
  • Bottom Layer: implementation details, including the control element

So for example a Moog Ladder would be:

  • Top Layer: 4 pole, low-pass, with resonance
  • Middle Layer: 4 single-pole low-pass sections in series, with feedback
  • Bottom Layer: transistor cascade ladder

And a state variable filter would be:

  • Top Layer: 2 pole, multi-mode
  • Middle Layer: 2 integrators and an inverter, in a loop
  • Bottom Layer: the circuit, perhaps OTAs[1]

Moog ladder

The Moog ladder filter is like that Zen Koan that all students of the synthesizer electronics temple meditate upon. "Oren Leavit"[2]

https://www.allaboutcircuits.com/technical-articles/analyzing-the-moog-filter/

https://www.allaboutcircuits.com/technical-articles/small-signal-open-loop-transfer-function-moog-filter/

Tim Stinchcombe's paper, "Analysis of the Moog Transistor Ladder and Derivative Filters," where he compares transistor and diode ladder filters.

http://www.timstinchcombe.co.uk/synth/Moog_ladder_tf.pdf

ladder filter variations: http://www.till.com/blog/archives/2005/03/ladder_filter_v.html

Roland MS20

Ian Fritz threeler

Mutant vactrol

3-pole, 4-pole, etc - without cascading 2-pole SVFs.

Leapfrog topology as implemented by Matthew Skala. The original ARP2600 filter is a clone of the Moog Ladder. The later ARP2600 filter has the same filter topology, but implemented inelegantly to get around the patent. https://files.northcoastsynthesis.com/msk-007.pdf (page 69 of the PDF) One of the important properties of this topology is that it in some sense minimizes component dependence - which is important for keeping the shape of the curve reasonably consistent when tuning it, given that I'm trying to keep five OTAs tracking each other. If you like implementation details, you might also like the way I'm using different linearizing-diode currents to set the fixed proportion between the different integrator time constants.[2]

Steiner Parker

The Steiner Parker is a rare exception. It's a classic Sallen-Key filter hacked up with biased diodes as controlled resistors.

Wasp

The Wasp filter is a State Variable with 4069 inverters replacing the inverting opamp in the integrators. Certainly the overdrive characteristics of the 4069 inverter are different than an opamp, but it's in a local feedback loop, and in a global feedback loop, and I think the OTA overdrive will predominate anyway.

EMS diode ladder

The EMS diode ladder filter is the same as the Roland diode ladder, and they're both Moog Ladder knockoffs, knocked off sufficiently to get around the patent.

Arp 2600

The original ARP 2600 filter is a clone of the Moog Ladder. The later ARP2600 filter has the same filter topology, but implemented inelegantly to get around the patent.

programmable op amp filters based on the lm4250?

https://modularsynthesis.com/kuzmin/polivoks/polivoks_vcf.htm Okay, that's a State Variable Filter with programmable op amps for the integrators. And a programmable op amp is basically an OTA, with an integration cap, and an output stage.

SVF

The State Variable Filter was introduced by the brilliant Dennis Colin in the ARP 2500 VCF. And his article is one of the classics: Dennis Colin The Electrical Design and Musical Applications of an Unconditionally Stable Combination Voltage Controlled Highpass, Bandpass, Lowpass, Band Reject Filter/Resonator Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, Dec 1971 http://www.guitarfool.com/ARP2500/DennisCollinPaper.pdf He didn't invent the SVF, but he was the first to voltage control it and apply it to music. The State Variable Filter has a long history, back to analog computers. It's also the same mechanism as the simple harmonic motion of a mass, spring, and friction. So it has a wonderful "universal" quality. The Oberheim filter, the Rhodes Chroma filter, and others, are mostly variations on this.

The Colin/ARP SVF puts the integrating cap in the integrator following the OTA. The Rossum/Oberheim SVF puts the integrating cap at the output of the OTA, shunted to ground.

Then there's the ARP 4075 VCF based around the LM3900 Norton amplifier. The first low distortion low noise high fidelity VCF. I just read the patent (US 4,011,466) on the 4075 and it is a fascinating read. That's a unique topology.

One thing the article fails to touch on is the feedback architecture. Feedback has a big impact on the sound, and the feedback design changed between Moog synth models. That is why players back then complained that the new models didn't sound like the Minimoog. My post in SDIY way back in 1997 here: http://search.retrosynth.com/synth-diy/search/lookit.cgi?-v9710.272

Alisa 1377 and 1387 have Sallen-Key ladder filters.

http://www.ruskeys.net/eng/base/alisa1377.php

http://www.ruskeys.net/eng/base/alisa1387.php

I wrote blog articles on them. Although they are in Japanese, they may help you.

https://houshu.at.webry.info/200704/article_1.html

https://houshu.at.webry.info/201101/article_3.html

Osamu HOSHUYAMA

Saitama, JAPAN.

  1. ^ Article "Analyzing the Moog Filter" reply by Donald Tillman, Synth-diy mailing list, 23:05, 22 August 2019
  2. ^ a b Article "Analyzing the Moog Filter", Synth-diy mailing list, August 2019

Implementation

The article says there are many ways to implement VC filters. What all are these different ways? --Rob Kam (talk) 11:21, 3 November 2019 (UTC)